Let the High Street Be Odd Again
Photo by Photo by Cheryl Ng on Unsplash on Unsplash
On a damp Saturday in a town that shall remain nameless — partly to protect the innocent, mostly because I can never remember whether it is in Lancashire or Yorkshire — I went looking for a lamp repair. The high street had three coffee chains, two charity shops, a vape shop, a bakery pretending to be a farm shop and a phone case kiosk. What it did not have, at first glance, was anywhere that would look at a broken lamp and say, yes, love, leave it with me.
Eventually I found a man in a workshop down a side street. He had a mug that said World's Okayest Electrician, a radio tuned to something ancient and a sign on the door that had not been updated since fax machines were a personality trait. He fixed the lamp in eleven minutes and charged me less than a round of flat whites. I left feeling something I had not felt on a high street in years: that the place had a use beyond somewhere to sit down with a pastry.
The flat-white fallacy
There is a particular kind of high street regeneration that has become almost universal. It goes like this: empty department store becomes faux-industrial food hall; bank becomes coffee chain; pub becomes coffee chain with slightly more wood; charity shops multiply like they are in a competition nobody wants to win. Councils call it 'vibrancy'. Estate agents call it 'a destination'. I call it a waiting room with oat milk.
I am not anti-café. I am anti-monoculture. A high street with ten places to buy a £4.50 latte and nowhere to buy a single curtain hook is not thriving. It is cosplaying as a functioning town. The coffee is fine. The town is not.
The problem is that we have confused polish with health. A nice independent café can be a lovely thing, but it is also a low-risk, high-margin business that looks good in a regeneration brochure. A shop that repairs accordions does not look good in a regeneration brochure. It looks like a mistake. It is also the reason someone might drive twenty minutes to that town on a wet Tuesday.
What weird shops actually do
Odd little shops are not just nostalgia. They are infrastructure. They create reasons to come into a town centre that have nothing to do with buying a sandwich and everything to do with solving a problem, pursuing a niche or simply being curious.
I am talking about the button shop where the woman behind the counter can tell you why your hem is crooked just by looking at you. The hardware shop that sells one screw of exactly the right size and will not make you buy a pack of fifty. The map and compass shop that still exists because walkers are loyal and slightly obsessive. The musical instrument shop that lets a twelve-year-old try a trumpet and does not laugh when they sound like a distressed goose. The fabric shop with bolts of cloth stacked to the ceiling and a owner who has opinions about interfacing.
These places are not cute. They are useful. They have personality. They have a point of view. You cannot swap them into another town without noticing. That is the whole point. A chain coffee shop in Stockport is the same as a chain coffee shop in St Albans. A shop that sells only left-handed teapots could only exist because someone, somewhere, decided that was a gap in the market and filled it with unreasonable devotion.
The economics of oddness
We cannot legislate for weirdness. You cannot send a memo from the council saying, please open a shop that sells vintage maps and fishing flies by Friday. But we can stop punishing the people who do it.
Rents and business rates are the obvious villains, but so is the obsession with chain-led regeneration. A landlord who would rather have a empty unit than a short lease for a pop-up selling second-hand vinyl is not protecting the high street. They are protecting a spreadsheet. Councils could do more with cheap market pitches, shorter leases, rate relief for genuinely independent traders and less reverence for the phrase 'anchor tenant'. An anchor can also drag you down.
Parking matters too. It is deeply unglamorous and deeply true. If the only easy way to visit a town centre is a £6 car park with a machine that only accepts coins, you have already lost half the people who might have bought a lamp fitting and a birthday card.
A test for councils
Here is a simple test for any high street plan. Could this plan be swapped into any other town in Britain without anyone noticing? If yes, start again. Does the plan include a shop that would make a fourteen-year-old stop and stare? Does it have somewhere to buy a single curtain hook at 4.45pm on a Tuesday? Does it have a place where the owner knows the difference between a good coat button and a bad one?
Britain's high streets do not need another cosy coffee chain. They need the strange, specific, stubborn little shops that make a town feel like it was made by people rather than installed by a contractor. Bring back the odd. It is the only thing on the high street that cannot be franchised.